Wednesday, February 4, 2015

Doctor Who: The Twelfth Doctor #4

Posted by Geek-o-Rama Admin on 8:00 AM

What secrets are hidden by the Scindia family, a dynasty whose powerful roots trace back over a thousand years? What strange genetic modifications fuel the death cult of the Thuggee? And how does a humble Mumbai pickpocket figure into these world-changing events?

As each Thuggee sacrifice comes closer to waking the ancient Kali from her slumber, can the Doctor uncover the truth before her resurrection spells doom for India, Earth, and the galaxy?!

Writer:
Robbie Morrison
Artist:
Dave Taylor
Publisher:
Titan Comics

As mentioned in my review of last issue, I'm still a little on the fence about this series. Though it had a strong opening storyline, last issue left me a little cold. One thing is clear though. If the TV show is content to be a series of mostly serial episodes, connected by an overarching plot, then the comic mini series is the exact opposite. In fact, it's shaping up to just be a series of stories spread out over two or three issues!

Issue four doesn't break that trend and even 'one ups' the last storyline, being at least one issue longer than the last one. I just wish I found myself thinking the wait was worth it. I'm being somewhat hyperbolic mind. The issue certainly cranks up the amount of plot happening over the last one, letting all the individual story threads begin to meet one another and intertwine. The different personalities and how they clash certainly produce some interesting scenes, even if I feel the Doctor comes across as being a little too mean at times.

One thing is apparent though – the creative team are clearly enjoying being free of any restrains that a TV budget would land them with. This issue alone we have Indian temples, cavernous catacombs, a space station and Clara turning into...well, let's not spoil too much eh?

Overall it's a fun enough issue, even if it does have some of the same problems as last issue. Clara has literally nothing to do apart from become a literal plot point (nice to know the writer is following in Steven Moffat's shoes). From the writing this series, it does feel at times like the writer is contractually obliged to include Clara in the adventures, but would rather ditch her and write adventures about the people who have appeared this issue.

Perhaps it's true, so then I do have to give credit for adapting to the circumstances in the best possible way. But I don't know about you, but an Indian assassin and the daughter of one of the Doctor's off screen companion's, who grew up on tales of his adventures, sound like far more interesting characters to be off with the Doctor's exploring the universe than Clara. Sorry Clara.

It's an improvement on last issue by quite a way and it does end on a nice cliffhanger. I hope I've just been too quick to judge and the concluding issue of the story will have me seeing the error of my ways. I'm really hoping so. I really am.

Cover image courtesy of Titan Comics.

Doctor Who: The Twelfth Doctor #4 is available from Titan Comics or your local comics retailer.


Geek-o-Rama received a copy of this comic for the purpose of this review. All thoughts, comments and opinions are those of the individual reviewer.

0 comments:

Post a Comment

Search Site